Carbone's Pizza Hastings Lawsuit | Get the Full Story on the City Dispute | South Metro Scoop

What Happened

Carbone's Pizza is suing the City of Hastings for forcing them to close without following proper legal procedures.

The basics: The city bought Carbone's building to build a water treatment plant for PFAS contamination. But Carbone's had a valid lease until 2029. The city told them to leave by June 30, 2025—no hearing, no formal process.

The Timeline

April 2024: Carbone's renews lease until 2029

November 2024: City buys the building

March 2025: City orders Carbone's out by June 30th

June 2025: Carbone's closes

• Zero income for 5+ months

• $200,000+ to build out new location

• Employees lose jobs for 6 months

• City pays $25,000

October 2025: Lawsuit filed

What the Lawsuit Says

Carbone's makes five claims:

1. Illegal taking - City took their lease rights without fair compensation

2. No due process - No hearing or chance to make their case

3. Illegal eviction - City forced them out without proper authority

4. Business destroyed - City's actions caused massive financial damage

5. Wrong process - City should have followed formal legal procedures

The Core Fight

Carbone's: "You can't force us out without following the law."

City: "We bought the building. Your lease ended. Talk to your old landlord."

Here's the email exchange that sums it up:

Carbone's lawyer: "How can you force my client out without proper legal proceedings?"

City attorney: "I guess we disagree. The lease ended when we bought the building."

Why It Matters

If City Wins: Cities could buy buildings, declare leases ended, and force out tenants without hearings or proper compensation.

If Carbone's Wins: Cities must follow strict procedures—including hearings and fair compensation—even when buying property with tenants.

This affects every small business in Minnesota that leases their space.

Both Sides Have a Point

The City:

• PFAS is a serious health crisis

• Had to act quickly

• Bought property legally

• Gave $25K and helped find new location

Carbone's:

• Had valid lease until 2029

• Just renewed and invested in future

• $25K doesn't cover $200K+ in losses

• Constitutional rights matter even in emergencies

What Happens Next

The city will file their response. Both sides will exchange evidence. This could settle or go to trial.

Timeline: 1-2 years for final resolution

What's at stake: Whether Minnesota cities must follow constitutional procedures when displacing businesses, or can skip them by buying the building first.

The Bottom Line

Carbone's wants fair compensation and formal recognition that their rights were violated.

The city wants to quickly address public health without lengthy legal processes.

The court will decide where the line is between government power and business rights.

‍